Evaluation of CSC 300 presentation
Time contraint: Talk for 8 minutes or less, Q&A for 2 minutes or less. Penalty of 10 per cent possible for running overtime.


1.     Eye contact and speaking style.  Eye contact, comfortable style?  Speaking clearly and loud enough?   


        _____________  (10 points)

2.     Quality of slides.  Do the slides help organize the talk and add to  your understanding of the topic?  Do they distract from the talk itself?  


        _____________  (5 points)

3.    Presentation of FACTS in an unbiased manner.  Do you get a good idea of the state of the world in the area?  Are facts presented so that you could go and check them if you were interested?


        _____________  (10 points)

4.    Statement of a narrow, focused issue for resolution.  Does the issue "pop out" of the fact recitation?  Do you understand exactly what question the presenter is asking?


        _____________  (5 points)

5.     Coverage of alternative arguments.  Have alternate arguments been covered in a fair manner and attributed so that you could trace them if you were interested?  


        _____________  (20 points)

6.    Use of ethical principles and ethical analysis to come to a reasoned conclusion.  Does the presenter answer her own question?  Do you (even if you disagree) understand and respect the reasoning behind the presenter's conclusion?


        _____________  (50 points)

Comments:





TOTAL  _____________  (of 100 points).   Student Evaluations average:  ____________  less 20 points gives _______________  bonus points.

OVERALL Presentation score _____________________ (Instructor's score plus any bonus)