Oral Presentation Requirements
An important component of the grade in this course is an oral
presentation to the class about a current issue regarding
social impacts of computing technology. The topic
can be almost anything that is relevant to the course.
- You will be assigned a date on which to present. Your
presentation should be about 10 minutes in duration, 15 minutes
maximum.
Expect to lead a question and answer session afterwards.
- The topic should be focused.
"Email in Today's World" is too broad and would not be
acceptable. "Is
Spam causing a decline in email usage?" would be fine as it presents a
potential controversy about a clearly defined topic. "Software
Risks" is too vague. "Aircraft disasters and
Fly-by-Wire" is good.
- Select a topic about which you can present a controversy.
"How software patents work" is too bland. "Computer Scientist
seeks overturn of trivial patents" might be more controversial.
The topic must be about computer
technology; other technologies such as genetic manipulation or solar
energy are not acceptable. To identify a suitable topic a good
place to start is the textbook.
- The topic must be current.
The talk should center around an event or issue that occurred within
the last 3 months. For example, you can't talk about how flaws
in electronic voting systems cast doubt on the legitimacy of the
election of G. Bush in 2000. If there is some new computer voting
technology that appeared within the last 3 months, it's okay to refer
to the 2000 election fiasco as a motivating factor.
- It's okay to explain your personal interest in this topic and to
share your bias or opinion, but your talk must clarify the nature of
the controversy and present both
sides of the issue. Discuss both the benefits and the
disadvantages of technology as it relates to your issue.
- An important point you must include is an explanation of how the
technology works. You can't get full credit unless you explain how the
technology works and the role it plays in this issue. For
example, in a lecture about Electronic Voting, you would explain how
electronic voting machines operate and explain how the electronic
voting process differs from using paper ballots.
- Prepare a list of
all the references you use. You should investigate the topic
using a variety of traditional
library resources as well as online resources. Do not simply
summarize a chapter
from the textbook.
- You may not choose a topic presented by another student. Inform
the instructor in advance of your topic choice. Send
an email three days prior to the class meeting you are
scheduled to present containing a description of your topic and your
reference list. (If you are scheduled to talk Wednesday, the instructor
must receive your email before Monday.)
- It is suggested that you create a few overhead transparencies of
the key points in your talk to show to the class. Create an
electronic version of your slides in Portable Document Format (PDF).
Include your reference list. Post the PDF of
your talk on the class "Discussion Board" on Blackboard prior to your
presentation. Give the discussion thread the name of your talk,
e.g., "U.S. fails to ratify E-Waste export limits".
- Create two multiple choice exam questions (and the solutions)
about your presentation. (You do not need to present the questions,
just include them in your electronic submission).
- Study the evaluation
criteria for
presentations that the instructor will use to grade your talk.
CSc 302
Home