Peer Evaluations for Project Teams

I’m working on the assignment of evaluation teams for the project (see http://users.csc.calpoly.edu/~fkurfess/Courses/480/F11/Project/Project/Team-Evaluations.html).As a team, please look at the project list below or at http://users.csc.calpoly.edu/~fkurfess/Courses/480/F11/Project/Project/Teams.html and select your top two choices of teams you'd like to evaluate. I will then assign the evaluation teams.

F.K.









Section 1


Team 1: Something with Music



Team 2: Social Intelligence



Team 3: Dreamteam



Team 4: Board Game AI



Team 5: SemanticMediaWiki



Team 6: PacMan



Team 7: NLP and Information Extraction










Section 3


Team 9: PacMan Ghosts



Team 10: Optical Character Recognition



Team 11: Stealth Game



Team 12: Texas Hold Em



Team 13: Evolutionary Algorithms



Team 14: PacMan



Team 15: Translation of Asian Languages to English

0 Comments

Project Milestone Feedback Templates

I’ve added the templates I'm using for the evaluation of the project milestones toh the Web page describing the project, http://users.csc.calpoly.edu/~fkurfess/Courses/480/F11/Project/Project.html in the "Grading" part at the bottom of the page. 
For Milestone Week 4, the emphasis is on the aspects below

User Feedback
initial reactions, criticism, suggestions, etc. from users of the alpha prototype or to design sketches
possible design modifications, changes in implementation
System Design
overview of the functional parts of the system
block diagram, class hierarchy
Prototype and Implementation
restrictions in functionality
implementation language, development tools
instructions for installation and basic use
Evaluation Plan
description of evaluation methods
detailed instructions for performing the evaluation
explicit evaluation criteria (questions, metrics)
0 Comments

A2 Wumpus World Available

  • The second assignment, where your agent has to navigate the Wumpus World, is available now. Note that you have to submit two parts: first a description of the knowledge representation and reasoning methods you’re planning to use, and then the actual implementation.
0 Comments

More Details on AI Nugget Grading

I’ve modified the section on grading for the AI Nugget presentations by including the typical allocation of the score within the grading categories:

Grading Criteria
The distribution of points I intend to use for the evaluation of this assignment is as follows; the items in parentheses indicate the typical point distribution for that part:
  • Topic proposal: 20% (Title 5, Abstract 10, References 10)
  • Final version of presentation slides or notes: 30% (Content: 20, Structure 5, Appearance 5)
  • Delivery of presentation: 50% (Topic Knowledge 20, Topic Difficulty 10, AI Relevance 5, Presentation Delivery 5, Supporting Evidence 3, Presentation Structure 3, Audience Interest 2, Timing and Length 2)
0 Comments

Quiz Makeup Opportunity

If you're unhappy about your score in a quiz, you can increase it buy submitting alternative questions for the quiz, together with proposed answers.
Here are the guidelines for these questions:
- you need to indicate for which quiz (by week or by topic) the questions are intended
- each question adds up to five points to your overall quiz score; if I need to revise the question or answers, you may get fewer points
- you can submit several questions, but your overall quiz score won't be higher than 100 points
- please formulate the questions as plain text format according to the template below. Multiple-choice are my preferred option, but multiple-answers (where more than one answer is correct), fill-in-the-blank, calculated answers, and several others are also available. I've tried free-form text answers as well, but grading those in Blackboard is really tedious - far worse than the paper equivalent.  

Question Template:

This is a template for a multiple choice question. Which of the following options is the correct or most suitable answer?
[ ] Answer 1 [10%] Why is it incorrect?] 
[ ] Answer 2 [30%] [Why is it incorrect?]
[X] Answer 3  [100%] [Why is it correct?]
[ ] Answer 4 [0%] [Why is it incorrect?]

The two columns in square brackets indicate the amount of (partial) credit, and feedback to the student for the selected answer.
0 Comments

Quiz Week 4

The quiz for this week will be available on Tuesday from 9:30 to 11 for the first section, and from 4:30 - 6 pm for the afternoon section.
It will cover “Uninformed Search Methods,” the material for Week 3; see the
schedule for mappings to the text book and the slides.
0 Comments